Jill, from rhapsodyinbooks.wordpress.com, and I would like to get a conversation started about what criteria bloggers (critics, casual reviewers, et al) use to rate books. Although some of us (me) use a 4.0 rating system and others (the rest of the civilized world) use a 5.0 system, the criteria should be the same. This all started because Jill and I read the same book, enjoyed it a lot, but gave very different ratings based on genre. We would love to hear what y'all have to say. Whether you respond to Jill's blog or mine doesn't matter. We will be sharing the responses on both. Let's see if we can generate a discussion that might help us all better identify what we are looking for in a book (whether it be print, ebook, or audiobook). Please weigh in. We are anxious and excited to share the comments.